The Heyday of the Percheron
If you read anything about the British heavy horse breeds, the British Percheron is always included as an established and respected member of the club. However, if one was to base its standing only on the numbers entered in the stud book, the Percheron could be considered as a footnote to our draught horse history; even in its most successful year (1944) the number of females registered stood at only one fifth of the equivalent figure for the Shire. (119 against 584) But talking to older horsemen another picture emerges; not only was the Percheron well regarded for its inherent qualities, but Percherons also seem to be more widespread and more numerous than the pedigree figures would suggest.
Three cross-bred Percherons in the south of England. © Eric Guy/the Museum of English Rural Life.
Although it is well known that Percherons were very common in the Fens, photos and other snippets of information point to their existence in many other parts of the country. For instance, in addition to the Fenland counties, Stanley Chivers cited Yorkshire, Suffolk, Huntingdonshire, Bedfordshire, Hertfordshire and Leicestershire, as well as Scotland, and, equally vaguely, ‘the South and West of England,’ as areas where Percheron stallions travelled in 1932.
By the late 1940s, the Percheron had become much more common and was found in many more parts of the country. In Northumberland, for example, one of the coal mines on the coast had 60 Percherons to run the associated farms of 3000 acres. This was probably Hartley Main Collieries, which did register some horses, and whose stallion, Canewdon Sensation, won his class at the 1948 Royal Show, whilst in Berwick, Percherons had been reported at the Berwick stallion parade since 1939.
Further south, in the East Riding of Yorkshire, when Geoff Morton bought his first horse in the 1950s, a grey mare which showed signs of some Percheron blood, he first tried her with a Percheron stallion, which the stallion man for the local Shire Hiring Society would put in the horsebox for any customers who preferred the Percheron. On the other side of the Pennines in Manchester, where my first farrier learnt his trade in one of the railway goods stables, they also had a few Percherons, in a stable otherwise full of Shires. He also volunteered how they liked the Percherons, because the Shires would always be stamping their feet to try and gain some relief from grease.
In other areas, however, there were some Percherons, but not very many. For example, at Leegomery, near Wellington in Shropshire, there was a farm which used Percherons in the 1950s, but this was the only place my informant had seen Percherons, either in Shropshire or his native Somerset. That is not to say they weren’t any Percherons there, a Somerset Percheron Horse Society having been formed in 1922, though I do not know how long it lasted, and during the war, Cannington training college used Percherons to teach members of the Women’s Land Army.
Early Introductions
Unlike the native breeds, in the early days after their introduction in 1916, Percherons were spread thinly over the country, mostly on the estates of wealthy landowners who initially formed the nucleus of Percheron breeding. From the beginning, more stallions were imported, and more male foals were registered than was necessary to perpetuate the pedigree population. This was because the Percheron stallion was most often used on mares of other breeds, but accounts of their progeny are almost non-existent, partly because they had no possibility of being graded up to pedigree status.
Numbers of Percherons grew only slowly during the 1920s, set against a dramatic fall in horse breeding after the First World War. This was due to the surplus created during the war, the motor lorry which cut the market for town geldings, and the fall in arable acreage due to the cheap food coming from overseas. By 1930 the agricultural horse population had dropped 30% in eleven years.
Stallion licensing
March Viking, champion stallion at the Percheron Society’s shows in 1935, 1936 and 1937. Owned by HH Truman, he was the type of stallion who left his mark amongst the working horses of the Fens.
Outside pedigree circles, most horses left no written records, but we can gauge the changes in horse breeding by the number of stallions used each year. In 1920, the Government initiated compulsory licensing for travelling stallions, keeping records of stallion numbers for each breed. The first decade of records illustrates the steep decline in horse breeding. Comparing the years 1920 and 1930, the Shire stallions suffered the biggest fall, at approximately 68%, whereas the Clydesdale dropped 56%, and the Suffolk 30%. By contrast, Percheron stallion numbers increased a little, though because the breed was still getting established and was at a very low level, the figures are statistically insignificant.
The decline of the town gelding during the twenties affected the Shire more than the other breeds because the Shire was bred principally as a town horse; it was on the hard streets that its size and weight were valued to move heavily loaded drays. In Scotland and northern England, the Clydesdale performed a similar function and also suffered, but as the existing stock of town geldings got increasingly old, both breeds saw a partial reverse in fortunes in the mid-thirties as replacements were needed. Clydesdale stallion numbers, however, increased more than the Shire, and since it had suffered less in the twenties, by 1939 there was one Clydesdale stallion for every five Shires. (In 1920 the proportion was one to eight)
Two plough teams of Percherons in Cambridgeshire.
Clean-legged Horses
The Suffolk, meanwhile, had suffered less during the twenties. Then in the thirties, as the demand for clean legged horses increased, Percherons and Suffolks became much more popular, the Suffolk stallion numbers increasing by 80%. By 1939 there were more Suffolk stallions than Clydesdale stallions, and one Suffolk stallion for every four Shires. The success of the Suffolk was primarily because he was an agricultural horse, and as such, he became more popular as the farmers’ opportunity to make a profit by selling a gelding for town work diminished. In the town, if the Shire’s weight gave better traction, his added height gave a higher position for the hame hook, making a better angle of draught when hitched to a high splinter bar, and his hair at least wasn’t getting full of mud, for farm work these characteristics were disadvantages. Even on the farm, if the power of the Shire were advantageous for ploughing heavy clay and pulling the binder, as the number of tractors increased, it was precisely this type of heavy job which the tractor took over.
Changes in Farming
The late twenties and early thirties were a tough time in farming. The farmers’ fall-back policy of cutting costs, complaining to Government and hoping for the best, had not worked. Many went bankrupt, whilst others sacked most of their workers, let the land revert to grass, and farmed with the proverbial dog and a stick.
By the mid-1930s many farmers realised that the old system of farming was no longer working and started to do things differently. This era saw the introduction of the portable milking bail, poultry folded over the fields and bred for production, whilst the traditional arable rotations, which usually included one year under grass and clover and a time-consuming year of hoeing turnips for animal feed, were losing favour. Instead, a longer ley of three or four years, using improved strains of clover and grass, became more popular, allowing subsequent corn crops to be grown with less fertiliser. All these changes, although many had agricultural benefits, were driven by economic efficiency.
The drive for efficiency also extended to the power source. For larger farmers who could justify the initial outlay, buying a tractor allowed them to get ahead with heavy cultivations and save on labour, but in the thirties few farmers could imagine farming without horses. In a time of tight finances, horses still had an advantage in that they could be fed off the farm, eating products which were making poor prices, rather than petrol or paraffin which had to be bought in. Efficiency-minded farmers, not surprisingly, also looked at the horses themselves. Why breed and feed a slow-moving horse that was 17 hands or more and weighed 18 cwt, in hope of a profit from the diminishing market for town horses, when you could do the same work with a 16 hand, 16 cwt, active, clean-legged horse, which required less handling, less feed and was quicker about his work?
This argument wasn’t new, it had been well made during the First World War, when the deficiencies of the British-bred horse for army purposes were laid bare, namely its lack of toughness and activity, its inability to thrive on a poorer diet, and its poor legs. Although those with army experience were aiming to promote the resilient Percheron-type horse that was imported from America, for those who could not get their hands on one of the few Percherons that the French Government allowed to be exported, the Suffolk seemed to share many of its advantages.
By the mid-30s, however, there were enough Percherons and Percheron crosses on the ground for farmers to see the results of using Percheron stallions on mares of other breeds. As others followed suit, the number of Percheron stallions more than doubled over the decade. In northern Cambridgeshire, southern Lincolnshire and Huntingdonshire, for example, hundreds of Shire mares had been mated with Percheron stallions by 1934, though there were also plenty of others covered by Suffolk or Clydesdale stallions. In the second half of the decade the use of Percheron stallions intensified as more were licensed, and increasingly they were covering half and three-quarter-bred Percheron mares.
A Percheron/Clydesdale horse at work hoeing roots on Chivers farms. When going down the road, a britchin would be used, but it was dispensed with in the field as the drag of the tool prevented it from running up the back of the horse.
Two Shire/Percheron cross plough horses.
The Second World War
Then in 1939 everything changed. With German U boats sinking merchant ships, sending the imported food that Britain relied on to the bottom of the sea, food production suddenly became of national importance. The need was to fill people’s bellies, so priority was given to growing corn and potatoes, and farmers were restricted to keeping only as much livestock as could be fed from the farm itself. This was a blow for the pig and poultry specialists, and for the dedicated stallion owner who relied on bought in fodder. Those with the most stallions were hit hardest, and many fine horses were gelded or sent to slaughter. From the Government’s point of view, although the country needed power to work all the extra land being ploughed up, there was no time to wait for next year’s foal crop to reach working age, so rather than supporting stallions, it turned to the tractor. This caused, between 1939 and 1941, a drop of 33% in the number of licensed Suffolk and Shire stallions, with the Clydesdale and the Percheron falling by 23% and 11% respectively. Nonetheless, all available mature horses were still desperately needed to work the land, and with petrol rationing, demand also increased for town horses.
For the Percheron, the lack of allocated rations to feed stallions was a minor setback, as most entire horses were in the hands of farmers. Anyway, unlike stallions of other breeds, many Percheron stallions were earning their keep throughout the year by working in harness outside the covering season. The tractability of the Percheron, exemplified by the working stallions, was an important reason for its rising popularity. In the past, breeding for temperament in Britain had not been a high priority as there were plenty of skilled men to break in youngsters and get them to a stage where they were manageable, but the Percheron, partly because the stallions in France were always worked, had any bad temper bred out of them, or if they were difficult, they were eaten! A docile horse was particularly advantageous when young farm workers joined the forces and older ones went to more highly paid factory jobs, leaving a lack of skilled horsemen. Farmers instead had to rely on less active older men, boys and Land Army girls, many of whom were completely new to farm work and to horses.
Part-bred Percherons at a wartime ploughing match.
Another asset of the Percheron was his good legs and feet, it being impossible to read anything on the subject where these features were not commended. The hard feet were also a legacy of the Percheron’s history, because many horses, including stallions, were used on the roads, as coach horses in the 18th century and as omnibus horses in the 19th century. But there is another reason why the Society always made a point of emphasising the quality of the Percheron’s feet. Though they were too polite to spell it out, everyone knew, as one horseman put it, that “the Shires, Clydesdales and Suffolks didn’t have very good feet, though the breed societies wouldn’t want to admit to it.”
The Percheron Society also promoted the Percheron’s longevity and its capacity for work, a characteristic that anyone with eyes could see, but one of the Percheron’s greatest assets was its ability to thrive on less food. If this attribute appealed to the practical cash-strapped farmer in the 1930s, in a time of war and rationing, it was doubly so. In a booklet produced by the Society, Stanley Chivers was quoted as saying that his Percherons only consumed 2/3 the amount of hard feed as the Clydesdales he once used. Although some may have dismissed this as mere propaganda, when the Ministry reinstated rations for travelling stallions, they allowed Percheron stallions 3 cwt each month, whereas a Shire or Suffolk stallion was allocated 5 cwt! Farmers reading this cannot have failed to realise that if they had Percherons they could potentially save three quarters of a ton per horse over a nine-month feeding period.
Given the Percherons qualities, at a time when practicality rather than fashion or tradition was paramount, it is not surprising that the use of Percheron stallions doubled from a wartime low of 82 in 1941, to an all-time high of 164 in 1945. By comparison, the Shire stallions never again regained their 1939 level, the Clydesdales nearly did, the Suffolks did a little better than the Clydesdales, whilst the Percheron exceeded its pre-war level by 79%.
By the end of the war there were almost as many Percheron stallions on the roads as Suffolks or Clydesdales. Even though the agricultural press had largely lost interest in horses, (many carrying full-page adverts for tractors!) local papers continued to report Percheron stallions in use from Cornwall and Devon in the south to Caithness and Orkney in the north. At the Berwick stallion parade in 1946, for instance, all four horses forward were Percherons,11 and even at Derby, a bastion of Shire horse breeding, one of the nine stallions that year was a Percheron. However, it was in the Fens that the density of Percherons was at its greatest. In Whitlesey, for instance, four stallions would set out every Monday morning from the Angel pub on their route to cover mares. Of these stallions, one was a Shire, but the other three were Percherons, one from H H Truman of March, one from Chivers, the third belonging to Arthur Drury from Postland. The legacy of these travelling stallions was felt well into the 1950s; Ron Creasey, a Yorkshire horseman travelling to the Broads by train, recalled seeing dozens of grey Percherons turned out on the Saturday afternoon as the train passed through the Fens.
Briton, the 1st prize winning ½-bred Percheron at the Percheron Society’s 1942 Autumn Sale. He made 220 guineas, and was just the type people were looking for, only a smattering of feather and a small head distinguishing him from a purebred Percheron.
Despite the popularity of the Percheron in the 1940s, the heyday of the Percheron horse in Britain turned out to be little more than a butterfly’s summer. By 1950, it didn’t seem to matter how good a horse you had, because no-one wanted them; the country’s working horses were disappearing. In the three years leading up to 1950, a quarter of the country’s heavy horses vanished. The reason usually cited is the tractor, which, with the new hydraulic arms were becoming much more useful, but that was just part of the picture. After years in the armed forces, many returning men were not prepared to accept the low wages and long hours of the horseman, or the archaic practises associated with horse work. In addition, farmers who previously had had nothing to do with tractors had learnt to get along with them during the war, and with the good profits earned during wartime, could afford to buy one. Then with the 1949 Agriculture Act, the Government committed to supporting farmers by guaranteeing a price for everything they produced, and with cheap fuel, why not get rid of the horses and replace them with something else which would return a profit?
Of course, that wasn’t the end for horses, as they remained the preferred motive power for some work, particularly for carting jobs like feeding outlying stock, for row crop work and for working wet land. But as the good old reliable horses died, few people had bothered to train the next generation, so horses got fewer and fewer. Had the working horse continued for longer than it did, the Percheron may have become much more common, just as it did in America. In tough economic times, the Percheron’s popularity was entirely due to its practical capabilities – strength, endurance, docility, thriftiness, and its good legs and good feet. In most parts of the country the Percheron was not visible for long enough into find its way into the hearts and minds of the population, but for anyone who values a horse for its inherent usefulness, the Percheron had, and still has, much to recommend it.
With thanks to the British Percheron Society for the use of pictures 2, 4, 5 and 7.