Mowing Hay with Horses

Most domesticated horses will eat hay at some point in their lives, and if you have heavy horses, making hay is one job that you can very usefully do for yourself. Although turning the hay and bringing in the crop are relatively straightforward jobs, cutting the hay is more challenging. Compared with most horse-drawn tools, the mower is a complicated piece of engineering and requires good adjustment to work well, and with the cutter bar, it is also potentially dangerous, so safe procedures are essential.

There are a number of ways of using horses for cutting hay, each of which has its own advantages and disadvantages; you can use a traditional mower, a modified horse-drawn mower, or a modern mower behind a ground drive hitch cart or one powered by an engine.

With a traditional horse-drawn sickle-bar mower, two horses are usually required, though many companies produced mowers for a single horse, though these are rare, and spare parts are even rarer. The two-horse mowers cut a swath of four foot six to five feet, though some American models could have a cutter bar of up to six feet long. The drive comes from the two wheels which transfer the movement to the knife via a combination of gears. Depending on the model of mower, the gears may be enclosed in a gearbox running in oil, or open, usually with a big ring gear attached to the wheels which engages with a small cog thus multiplying the revolutions. Generally, the enclosed geared mowers are of later manufacture, more efficient, and safer because there are no open gears for lines, clothes or fingers to get caught in. The last stage in the gears is to turn the rotation through 90 degrees, there being a shaft going forwards from the axle which lines up with the cutter bar just in front of the wheels. At the end of this shaft is a small flywheel, with a pin mounted off-centre onto which the pitman stick is attached, so the circular movement of the flywheel is changed to a back and forth movement in the pitman, and thence to the knife. The knife consists of a number of triangular blades attached to a length of steel which runs back and forth along the top of the cutter bar. Bolted onto the cutter bar are a number of fingers or guards, which provide the shear against which the triangular knife sections move, thus cutting the grass using a similar action to a pair of scissors.

Ambleside mowing scene

A horse-drawn mower in Ambleside, circa 1900. Neither horse is wearing a britchen, which makes backing up harder when the knife gets clogged, but it is less harness for a sweaty job such as this. The mower has open gears, and, as you would expect in hilly terrain, a short cutter bar.

An old engine-powered horse-drawn mower

A single-horse mower with an engine to move the knife, here used to cut round the edges of the field and the sides of ditches. Motor-driven mowers were produced from about 1930, but the horse needed to be accustomed to the noise as well as the vibration when stationary. As with other single-horse mowers, including ground-drive models, short shoulder chains as found on a cart are not used, but long traces to a swingletree are employed instead to equalise the pressure on the horse’s shoulders, which can be considerable on a ground-drive mower.

There are some significant problems with old mowers even before you start to use them; first you need to find one, most are fairly worn and often have missing or broken bits and finding parts can be well-nigh impossible. The easiest solution is to get an International (McCormick Deering) mower, a number 7 or 9, which were produced in America in vast numbers and for which some new parts are produced, albeit in America, but like me, you might have to import the mower too, though a number of American firms do recondition them, so you can get an as-new machine. Even if you do this, you still need to know how to set it up and adjust it.

Adjusting a mower

The most common maintenance job on a mower is sharpening the knife. Older knives can be sharpened with a file, but newer ones made of harder steel require the judicious use of a small angle grinder, used without much pressure and for short periods to avoid blueing the steel. When sharpening, both the length of the bevel and the shape of the triangular sections need to be maintained, so the angle of shear between the ledger plate and the knife section remains as it is designed. Having a dull knife dramatically increases the draught of the mower.

For the shearing action between knife and ledger plate to work well, the knife must run close to the ledger plate, but it should also move freely. Both functions are regulated by the clips which hold down the knife against the ledger plates. These are adjusted with a hammer. Starting with the outside clip, the one furthest from the mower body, the end of the knife is pulled under the clip, and then you can move it to see if there is free play between the last knife section and the ledger plate. If there is, pull the knife from under the clip and hammer on the front of the clip to bend it down. Try it again and repeat the process if still too loose. If, however, the clip is stopping the knife from moving freely, keep the knife underneath the clip and hammer the middle of the clip, where it rises in a semicircle. This will loosen the hold on the knife. You then repeat the process for every clip. These are the basic regular adjustments you need to do on the cutter bar, but there are a couple more considerations to know about. The first is knife registration. This is the position where each knife section is at the end of each stroke, it should be when the centre of the knife section aligns with the centre of the finger. This is adjusted by a rod between the inside shoe of the cutter bar and the mower body, and there is a similar adjustment to adjust the lead of the cutter bar. The lead is the amount the far end of the cutter bar is in advance of the inner shoe when at rest, because when the mower is in use, the drag on the cutter bar pulls the end of the cutter bar backwards and into a straight line with the pitman stick, which is ideal for minimising the draught.

In addition, there are the more obvious maintenance tasks of oiling or greasing all the moving parts, replacing the gearbox oil and checking the tightness of all the bolts, particularly along the cutter bar. For old machines in particular, you also need to be absolutely sure of the strength of the pole, the neck yoke, the swingletrees and the pins that they are attached with, as well as the security of the seat and seat post.
Because the mower is complex, for anyone without an experienced mentor who is well versed in mowing and uses a mower regularly, I would advise buying the Horse Drawn Mower Book by Lynn Miller, which goes into all the essential detail for using and adjusting a mower, as well as what to look for and what to do if you want to restore one to working condition.

The Horses

Turning to the horses, a mower should be a moderate pull in average conditions, but it can get tough, requiring greater exertion. The horses also need to walk where you want them to, one horse close to the standing grass, and they need to pull at a moderate to fast walk, because this is when the mower functions best. There is also a considerable amount of vibration transferred to the pole and noise from the machine, and if something is not working right, you want horses that stop immediately you tell them, and to stand still once they have stopped. At the corners, you need to stop inches after the cutter bar has cut the last of the standing grass, lift the cutter bar, turn the horses round without going forward and send them on just as the cutter bar comes back into position and as you drop the cutter bar to the ground. All of this requires good horses, horses that are used to noise, vibration, work and doing what they are told. Mowing is no place for inexperienced horses, inexperienced drivers, or questionable machines. In fact I would go so far in saying that you should not try this unless two of those three factors are sorted; if your horses are new to mowing, then make sure the mower is good and that you know horses and mowers; if you are new to mowing, get someone knowledgeable to check the mower and use horses that have mowed before. Usually, having experienced help when doing a job for the first time is good advice, but in this case, although you might want someone experienced walking behind you, having someone there to help with the horses is not a good idea, the horses need to be past that stage. The reason is that a mower has a cutter bar, and you do not want to be anywhere near it. The very last thing you would want is someone leading the horse in front of the cutter bar. It does not take much imagination to realise what would happen if the horses went faster than the man, who, tumbling to the ground, is only feet in front of the cutter bar. For similar reasons, keep your children and dogs at home when mowing.

The presence of the cutter bar determines how you do everything with the mower. When you hitch the horses, the cutter bar must be in the vertical position, held in place by the stay rod. You then can either drive one of the horses over the pole, or lead them into position, then fasten them together at their heads and take the lines back to the mower seat. I usually use just one length of cord back from one bit, to my hands and forward to the other horse’s bit, as it is one thing less to drop as you work the levers whilst mowing. Those who use pairs reins often sit on the extra length of reins for the same reason. Then lift the neck yoke and fasten it to the bottom of the collar with the pole strap[s]. This should be close to the collars to keep the pole high, thus minimising the downwards pressure on the pole when the mower is at work. Then attach the traces. Because I use American harness, where the traces hang on the hip drops, I can hook all the traces by reaching over the pole from the side away from the cutter bar, but if you are using chains and back bands without cruppers, you have to go down the cutter bar side, in which case you do this trace first. The most reliable horse should go on the side nearest the cutter bar.

Then when you get to the field, you go behind the cutter bar, loosen the nut on the stay rod, and lower the cutter bar, all the time making sure you hold the bar away from the knife because the knife moves as you lower it, because it could easily sever a finger.

mowing hay with Percheron horses

With fit well-trained horses, a properly adjusted mower and the grass standing up, mowing is not an arduous job.

clearing the cutter bar

The horses wait patiently while I free the cutter bar from this very tall grass in a dunging area. What you can’t see is that I still have the cords in my hand, the mower is out of gear, and that I am moving the grass with a stick.

Using the mower

Then, if I haven’t put you off, you are ready to go. As you sit on the seat, depending on the model of mower, there are two levers to your right and a foot lever. The foot lever lifts the cutter bar just a little, so the outer shoe no longer rests on the ground. The big lever also lifts the cutter bar; in its middle position it lifts the same amount as the foot lever, but when pulled back more the end of the cutter bar is raised about 18 inches from the ground. Pushing the lever forward drops the cutter bar to the ground. The shorter lever adjusts the tilt of the cutter bar, so if the crop is laid, the front of the fingers can be pointed downwards to get underneath it.

Before you start the horses, first put the mower into gear with the clutch pedal, usually operated with the left foot, and have the lifting lever in its middle position so the cutter bar is just off the ground. Set your horses going and drop the bar just as you reach the standing grass. Once you gone once round the field, the horse next to the grass will have a narrow path cleared of hay by the grassboard at the end of the cutter bar. Keeping the horse walking in the right place allows the mower to cut its full width, but if your horse walks into the grass you will miss a bit and if he walks too far away, the inside of the knife will be running along the previously cut swath, and with traditional fingers, the knife will probably jam. You may clear this by backing up a step, which is easier if the horses have britchens, or you may need to clear the knife yourself. Whenever you get off the mower you MUST put it out of gear, always. If the horses move, even if they just lean forward, that knife will move. The other rule is always to clear any jam with a stick, not your fingers, because unlike the fingers on the cutter bar which can be replaced, you have only got one set!

If by now I have scared you off mowing, then I have done a good job because it is a demanding job and potentially dangerous. On the other hand, it is one of the most enjoyable and useful things you can do with horses once you get into it. The key is to have good horses, good horse skills, and a good mower.

detail of a horse-drawn mower

When turning at the corners, the cutter bar is raised a little off the ground which helps clear any grass before cutting the next side of the uncut block of grass.

turning the horses at the corner

As the horse side step 90 degrees to complete the turn, the cutter bar is dropped down just as the horses step forward and the cutter bar reaches the standing grass.

The disadvantage of traditional mowers is that they tend to jam, particularly in laid grass and thick grass. This is because the grass collects on the ends of the fingers, pushing the crop down under the cutter bar as it moves forward so it never reaches the knife to be cut. In America they often put three topless guards next to the inner shoe so they can dispense with the grassboard, leaving all the grass lying flat on the ground. Because this type of guard does not clog, I have these triangular topless guards along the whole length of the cutter bar, so it will even chomp through a cut swath.

 

detail of a cutter bar on a horse-drawn mower

The inner section of the cutter bar. The traditional finger, or guard, still with some green paint on it, forms part of the static part of the cutting mechanism, the ledger plates, theses ones are serrated, forming one half of the shearing action once the knife with its triangular sections has been slid into position. The three triangular guards near the inner shoe are topless guards.

a modified cutter bar on a horse-drawn mower

The whole cutter bar with the knife in position and topless guards along the whole length.

A more recent upgrade is the replacement of the old cutter bar with a double acting knife, where instead of having one knife and stationary ledger plates, two moving knives work against each other. The weight of these modern bars is significantly more than the traditional bar, so a jockey wheel is necessary, and additional modifications are required to the flywheel and the lifting mechanism.

 

Recent Developments

Moving away from traditional mowers, tractor mowers in this country are usually disc or drum mowers requiring very high speeds and a lot of torque, so are difficult to run using ground drive. In addition, most are mounted on a three-point linkage and are heavy, so using them on a hitch cart presents some challenges with balance. Trailed models can be used behind a hitch cart with an engine, but this is not a common solution. Much easier to run are the new double acting sickle bar mowers, the cutter bars made by the German company ESM being used on upgrades to traditional mowers, on mowers made by a couple of small-scale German manufacturers of horse drawn equipment, and they are widely used in America, particularly on the new machines made by I and J Manufacturing, an Amish company from Pennsylvania.

Besides being double acting, the ESM cutter bars have a staggered placement of the sections along the knives. This means that at any given moment, some of the knives are completely in alignment and are cutting nothing, whereas further along the knife some are at the start of the cut, some are in the middle and some are finishing. This contrasts with the tradition knife where every section is doing the same thing at the same time. The result is the ESM cutter bar takes 1/3 less power to do the same work, a significant technological breakthrough for horse farmers.

I and J produce a traditionally styled, ground-drive mower with this modern cutter bar, allowing two horses to cut an eight-foot swath, as well as a trailed mower with its own engine to go behind a hitch cart. Alternatively, they also offer what is essentially a two wheeled trailer on which a three-point ESM mower is mounted, which can then be pulled by a hitch cart with an engine, or can be driven by one of their ground drive hitch carts, or if you had a horse lame, it can also go behind a tractor.

 

A modern horse-drawn mower

A Swiss-built horse-drawn mower featuring two counter-reciprocating knives.

A trailed horse-drawn mower

I and J Manufacturing’s trailed mower, being driven by a ground-drive hitch cart.